Washington Business Fall 2016 | Judicial Review | Page 7
2016 judicial scorecard
Employment Law (continued)
Becerra Becerra v. Expert Janitorial, LLC
181 Wn.2d 186 (2014)
In Becerra Becerra¸ the court expanded the reading of who a joint employer is under
Ch, 49.46 RCW
AWB disagrees with this decision.
LaCoursierre v. CamWest Development, Inc.
181 Wn.2d 734 (2014)
In LaCoursierre, the court found that an investment in an employer by an employee is not
a wage rebate under Ch. 49.48 RCW
AWB agrees with this decision.
Demetrio v. Sakuma Bros.
183 Wn.2d 649 (2015)
In Demetrio, the court found that piece rate workers must be separately paid for all
rest breaks.
AWB disagrees with this decision.
AWB filed an amicus brief.
Filo Foods LLC, v. City of SeaTac
183 Wn.2d 770 (2015)
In Filo Foods, the court found that the SeaTac City ordinance was not preempted by the
federal National Labor Relations Act, nor did it interfere in basic airport operations.
AWB disagrees with this decision including all dissents.
Becker v. Community Health Systems
184 Wn.2d 252 (2015)
In Becker, the court expanded the tort of wrongful discharge, requiring alternate remedies
to be exclusive to avoid the application of the tort claim.
AWB agrees with this decision.
Chief Justice Barbara Madsen concurred
Associate Chief Justice Charles Johnson concurred
Justice Susan Owens concurred
Justice Mary Fairhurst concurred
Justice Debra Stephens concurred
Justice Charles Wiggins concurred
Justice Steven Gonzalez wrote opinion
Justice Sheryl Gordon McCloud concurred
Justice Mary Yu concurred
Chief Justice Barbara Madsen concurred
Assoc. Chief Justice Charles Johnson dissented in part
Justice Susan Owens concurred
Justice Mary Fairhurst concurred
Justice Debra Stephens dissented in part
Justice Charles Wiggins wrote opinion dissenting in part
Justice Steven Gonzalez wrote opinion
Justice Sheryl Gordon McCloud concurred
Justice Mary Yu not on court
Justice James Johnson dissented in part
Chief Justice Barbara Madsen concurred
Associate Chief Justice Charles Johnson concurred
Justice Susan Owens concurred
Justice Mary Fairhurst concurred
Justice Debra Stephens concurred
Justice Charles Wiggins concurred
Justice Steven Gonzalez concurred
Justice Sheryl Gordon McCloud concurred
Justice Mary Yu wrote opinion
Associate Chief Justice Charles Johnson concurred
Justice Susan Owens wrote opinion
Justice Steven Gonzalez concurred
Justice Sheryl Gordon McCloud concurred
Justice Mary Yu concurred
Chief Justice Barbara Madsen concurred in dissent in part
Justice Mary Fairhurst concurred in dissent in part
Justice Debra Stephens wrote opinion dissenting in part
Justice Charles Wiggins concurred in dissent in part
Assoc. Chief Justice Charles Johnson wrote opinion
Justice Debra Stephens concurred
Justice Charles Wiggins concurred
Justice Steven Gonzalez concurred
Justice Sheryl Gordon McCloud concurred
Justice Mary Yu concurred
Chief Justice Barbara Madsen dissented
Justice Susan Owens dissented
Justice Mary Fairhurst wrote the dissent
special edition 2016
7