Vermont Bar Journal, Vol. 40, No. 2 Vermont Bar Journal, Fall 2017, Vol. 48, No. 3 - Page 39

BOOK REVIEWS T he B urger C ourt and the R ise of the J udicial R ight Linda Greenhouse and Michael J. Graetz (New York: Simon and Schuster, 468 pp, 2016) Reviewed by Ted Lawrence, Esq. In the introduction to The Burger Court and the Rise of the Judicial Right, Linda Greenhouse and Michael Graetz gamely (or inauspiciously) confide: When we told friends and colleagues that we were writing a book about the Burger Court, the response was almost universally one of surprise and the question was “Why?” Now that the book has been published, it’s fair to ask that question again. This isn’t because of the subject matter—Warren Burger’s time as chief justice, from 1968 to 1986, should be of great interest to lawyer and layman alike. Nor is it because the au- thors lack expertise—both Greenhouse, a former supreme court correspondent for the New York Times, and Graetz, a pro- fessor at Columbia Law, ought to be sure- footed guides to the Court’s cases and the era that gave rise to them. But they aren’t. The Burger Court is frus- trating and boring. The problems begin at the outset, as Greenhouse and Graetz describe their rea- sons for writing the book. First, they claim that the Burger Court has been “over- looked and under-studied.” Second, they argue that the opinions issued during Burg- er’s tenure were a “counterrevolution” that effectively unmade many of the Warren Court’s radical precedents, and paved the way for the “aggressive conservatism of the Rehnquist Court.” Both claims are wrong. Issues that the Burger Court addressed—affirmative ac- tion, campaign f 6RBFRFVFVЧwwrgF&"&pG&Vr&֖VBWW>( F&RFP7V&V7BbVFVBVvBƗF6FRЦ&FRB'W&vW"&W6FVBfW"&RbvF^( GFR7B6G&fW'67W&VP6W'B66RbFR7BfgGV'2B&"Ц&ǒFRRfW&vRW&Ц62&RFRg&V'vPB&Rf"F6FBFR'W&vW"6W'@6( B&V6VfVBV667'WF27FЧGWFv6VBFBGFW#G266W>( @RFRFw2&WBBFBFGFW.( @fRbFr&VVfW&ǗVB@fW"7GVFVBw&VVW6RBw&WG&RWVǐ6w&VBvVFW&VFR'W&vW 6W'B2( 66W'fFfR( Fr6v&W0G2&V6&BFFR6G&'fƖFFr7FFP&&F2&'FƖ֗FrƖ6ЧFbFRFVFVGB67FpF67&֖Fv7BvFW2BV( @RbFW6R&R66W'fFfR7F2ॖWBFW&RFw2bv6FR'W&rЦW"6W'B&fVBG2vFFf^( @vFWB&Vrf&6VBFF6'&V2ЦVFVG2g&G2Ɩ&W&&VFV6W76"bFP'W&vW"6W'Bv2fVBvF&V7F&W22w&VVW6RBw&WG6Bv2v@vfW3FV"7vW.( GFR'W&vW"6W'B6V@fRFRWfV&R6VBfRvPWfVgW'FW"'6&Ɨ6rFRFVFVG"&WV&rFBV&Ɩ266gVFr&RWV7&72F7G&7G>( F6( @6W&W2BFW2FrFw&RvFFP&VƗGFBFR'W&vW"6W'BFBw&V@FVFGf6RƖ6W2ff&VB'FPVgB&WGFW"&vVBfR6vЦVFvVBF2&VƗGBG&VBFWvF2w&Wb7FV6&ǒ&WV&Ɩ6VFvW0FRr6BFG2vFFRVV7FVBffЦ62vFVBFV&R'FBw&VVW6R@w&WG( 2fW&ǒƗF6vR2&Bvb&6r7F'7W&VR6W'@W7F6W2&RƗF62'WBFWfRFW"FW&W7G2F&W6FW2fWr'&Vb&w&2ЧVFFR'W&vW"6W'B6F2ƗGFP&6w&VBG2W7F6W2F22Vf'GRЦFR&V6W6R6&7FW"6WF6W2BW"Ч6V6FFW2&RvBR'&FfP7F'7&RFW&RFRFw2&VFW'0&VV&W"BFRV7W&Rg&v"Ч&V'W&vW"f"7F6Rv&VB2ƖfRЦ7W&6R6W6F2vF&Vv66'&vFRv2&F&FW066"B&fW76fF&W"f FRFWG&BƖ2FR'W&vW"6W'N( 2֗2Ч6bFW6RƗGFRFWF2g&G2&'6FW'2R&VFrFV6r"&Rw&VVW6RBw&WGgV6FV"FR2G'BFV"RЦ"26&B'F6֖fV7FVB6DRdU$B$"U$( "d#pFR( v"G'Vw>( B( v&v"FW'&&6( vWB66&RVFW2FRf7BFBFRs2( f7F2b7&R&VvF6VG&&RFR7&֖&6W7>( Ц26W6Rf"v''B6VV'&FW6PFBSfRf7F2WfW"BVB( 6VG&&RFR7&֖&6W7>( @&B6V7F7W&VR6W'B&6RЦGW&R2FW"'GVGf"ƗF6&&#W"7W&VVBBVVЦW2'W6bv&Rv277VVB2W"7W&fW"fW"F76VG2FW7FRFW6R6W"FW2FR'W&vW 6W'BFW2fR6RW&G2w&WpFvWFW"bFR66W2g&'W&vW.( 2FVЧW&R&fFW26FWBFB7GVFW2b6vPFV6626BFR&FW2FV6V@"bWrFR6W'BƗF72FB7W"Ч&VFVBFRw&Fr&6W72'WB@f2F6f6RG2'&FW"&wVV@FBFR'W&vW"6W'B&V&VFVBFRVFЦ6'FFR&vBFR6W'N( 2Ɩ&W&FV6Ч62&R7FvFW2B&RƖVǒF&RЦ6f"6RFRFVBw&V6R2766FRBF6P4G&Wrv&7F6W2&&ǐFR&Vb'W6W72G&67F2&Vf&P26&VW"2wW"Rv&VB2VFЧF"B&W6V&6767FBR&V6VfVB0B7VVFRg&FRVfW'6Gb֖6Цvr66"W6W72B2W&6FvFখbVFW&2W'G0VFFVB'&&W'B@&WfWvVB'WFW"w&6W7ख#2&WfWvVBFRF&BVFFb( 'W6W72B6W&6ƗFvЧFfVFW&6W'G>( VFFVB'&&W'@rBFBFRF6FVBFB3