UK CIGAR SCENE BLIND TASTING
CIGAR RATINGS
18 Months ago when we launched UK Cigar Scene we set out to review two cigars each month, one Cuban
and one from the ‘New World’. So after 18 months we decided it was about time to put all the cigars we have
reviewed to date into a table form so that you can get a clear view.
5
Rank
Cigar
Mark
Cuban/New World
1
Partagas D4
8.90
Cuban
2
Partagas D6
8.62
Cuban
3
Dunhill Signed Robusto
8.38
New World
4
H. Upmann No 2
8.19
Cuban
5
Partagas P2
8.14
Cuban
6
Oliva Series O Tubo
8.10
New World
7
Rafael Gonzalez Petit Corona
8.00
Cuban
8
Bolivar Belgravia
8.00
Cuban
9
H Upmann Magnum 56 2015 EL
7.95
Cuban
10
Alec Bradley Nico Puro Robusto
7.90
New World
11
Drew Estate Uncrown Robustos
7.86
New World
12
Punch Medal d'oro
7.67
Cuban
13
Flor de las Antillas Robustos
7.67
New World
14
Davidoff Nicaraguan Perfecto
7.62
New World
15
Dunhill 1907 Robusto
7.62
New World
16
Joya de Nicaragua Joya Red Robusto
7.62
New World
17
Ramon Allones Specially Selected
7.52
Cuban
18
Rocky Patel Tabaquero Robusto
7.43
New World
19
Tatuaje 7th Reserva
7.33
New World
20
H. Upmann Majestic
7.24
Cuban
21
Davidoff Winston Churchill Robusto
7.14
New World
22
Dunhill Heritage Toro
6.95
New World
23
Montecristo No 4
6.95
Cuban
24
Flor Dominicana Double Ligerio
6.90
New World
25
Hoyo de Monterrey Hermosos No.4 Añejados
6.76
Cuban
26
Montecristo Añejados
6.57
Cuban
27
Diplomatico No 2
5.95
Cuban
28
Invicta Honduran Robusto
5.05
New World