The Trial Lawyer Fall 2017 - Page 43

safety features needed to prevent CO poisoning injuries and deaths. crashes. Examples of such reports include: C. Ford Explorers • In August 2017, an officer reportedly “lost consciousness at the wheel… and struck a civilian’s vehicle in Massachusetts;” In July 2016, NHTSA’s Office of Defects of Investigation (“ODI”) opened a Preliminary Evaluation (“PE”) into reports of exhaust odors in the occupant compartments of 2011–2015 Explorers. At the time NHTSA had received 154 consumer complaints. Despite issuing three separate Technical Service Bulletins (TSB) to help guide technicians with procedures to address this problem, these numbers have steadily risen. Indeed, Ford has reported fielding over 2000 reports, while 791 consumers complained to NHTSA’s Vehicle Owner’s Questionnaire hotline. By late July 2017, ODI upgraded the investigation into an Engineering Analysis (EA). However, while the upgrade to an EA may seem like a step in the right direction, there remain significant causes for concern as NHTSA appears to be adopting the Ford talking points. Case in point, the agency recently stated that: “To date, no substantive data or actual evidence (such as a carboxyhemoglobin measurement) has been obtained supporting a claim that any of the alleged injury or crash allegations were the result of carbon monoxide poisoning, the alleged hazard.” Moreover, despite the defect’s high profile and significant potential for injury, ODI has been less than fort Z[]H[[و][\Y][ۈ[ܙ8&\\ۜHHK\\\[[[[ۙ\\H[ܛX][ۈ]HXX[ܙY[Hۘ\]HX^H[\[\B[[[[][\Y][ۂ]]Z[YX[[ٝ[X[ۈœXۜ[Y\˂]H[YH[YKܙ8&\XB[\\܈][]HZX\8%X\B[YYY^ܙ\\YۙY[BY \YY\\[\]X][ۜ˜[\H\YHXH\\Y[XܛH[H8%]H[Y[ۛXY^]\ \[]Y[\\[][\B([[H MH]\[XB\\Y[[Y8'X\H 8'B[\\ܜ]و\XHY\8'[ܙB[ ٙX\8)\ܝYX[؛[\8'H[8'[ܙH[ \B[]HYX\\XH\ۂ[ۛYH[Z\\[\'B([\[X\ MKH]ܝXX [YܛXHٙX\8'\Y][H][\[\\܋8'H[BZXH[8'\YXܛ[\قۘZ[YXX\H][[\\XYۋ[ܘ\Y[HYH] MB\ 'Bܙ\\YY]Hۘ\˜\X]Y]HXH[\\ܜœ[]H8'Y\X\][YX][ۜ'H]\H\[ۈۜ[Y\^ܙ\˂Y]HY]\]\[]]ۛH LHوH LH\Z[XYHH[YXH[\\ܜ˂][[؜X\[“]Z]\\\[X[H[\]YB[[\ˈXKH\\[BYX[؛[\]YYX[[[[Y\[]\][ۋ\HZ[YX\H\[و\X\[š\Y[^\KH]\HوB^\K[HYYX[ܜ[][ۂ]Y[]^\H[HZ[YY[\Y\ˈXXو\H[]Z\Y\[\[ٝ[\]Z\H\^^\[[\\™H\XX[[[Y\[HYB\^HوY][ۘ[^\ˈ[ܙ[ݙ\[[HXݙ\XHY[[[[˜HX\YK\[\[HXY\œY][Y\۝Z[^\[ۜXX^H܈X^H\K\[[ۂHXH[XYKHX[B\XXH]˂ˈݚ[XX[]H[]\][ۂ\X\[]\][ۈ[H\ۂ[ۛYH\H[H\X[\H[YKBۜ[Z[[^[]KH^\\B[Y\ٝ[YK\[[ˈ]B]] HZ[Y[\X[HYY[^\[\YH\B^\[HوYH\HوH[][ۋ܈\Yۋ][H[[][ۋYX[Y[ ܈\]\Hو\Y[[Z\[ۜˈ[[\]Z\H^\]XX[Y\[[HZ[[˜ۜX[ۋZ[[\\BX[Y[Y[ \X[H[[][ۋ[\X[YY[KYX[X[[[Y\[X\[ۋ[\X˂[ܙ[ݙ\][YH\HوB\]Y[ۈ]XKHY[B[[^\܈[\]H\\ق^\KX]\\][ۘ[܈ۜ[X[ \H\[ HZ[Y[\[H]\\HۙH܈[ܙH^\Y[]][H\X\H\Bوˈ[ Y\\و\HB۝[Z[][ۈ\H\]Y BZ[Y[[\X[HYY\B[^\]\Z[HH[X[ZYܘ][ۈ]^\وH[B\Y[KZ[[܈\^\B][ۋ\^\[[YYHXH^Z[[BHXXY\Z[][[B\[[\X\ˈ\X[K\[\˜[[X[ۈو]][ۋ\[\\[[[][ۜ[][[[ݘ[قH\X[H܈\\KY][ۘ[K[H]]HœXY[\H[\ܝ[[[[ X[B%Y[8%Z[Y[]BX\\[و]Y[K\\œ\X[\HYH[\\[[Hš[\H]\YHۙ]\H^\H›][][]\HH[\B[ ۘHYZ[HZ[Y[YYۙH܈[ܙH^\^Z[\[Y[ۈ[\HY[YX[Bݙ[Y]H]\Z[H]][HY[\^Y[B[وH^\KHY[H[[[[B]\H^\H][[\[[H\Hو[\Y\Y\YH