TRANSFUSION NEED IN ORTHOGNATHIC surgery - A REVIEW
Review Articles
( 2009 ) 53 and Rummasak et al . ( 2011 ) 42 were not retained because they did not give a transfusion rate . The following papers were included in the no-predonation policy : Ash and Mercuri , 1985 7 ( 8 patients ); Choi et al ., 2009 54 ( 61 patients ); Kretschmer et al ., 2008 47 ( 36 patients ); Landes et al ., 2008 14 ( 13 patients ); and Stewart et al ., 2001 49 ( 2 patients ). Three papers with a predonation policy were retained in this category : Blau et al ., 1992 55 ( 30 patients ); Moenning et al ., 1995 17 ( 155 patients ); and Posnick et al ., 2010 56 ( 34 patients ). Posnick et al . ( 2010 ) 56 did not indicate a criterion of transfusion but believed a level below 7 g / dL ( Hc = 21 %) was a definite indication for transfusion , with room for evaluation of the clinical need and transfusion before that level is reached if necessary . Blau et al . ( 1992 ) 55 stated that they did not use uniform criteria for postoperative transfusion ; indeed , many patients received transfusion postoperatively before documentation of the postoperative hemoglobin concentration . Pooling of the other data showed adherence to equal and strict transfusion criteria when considering autologous or homologous blood transfusion . The ‘ arithmetic ’ overall requirement of blood transfusion is 12.4 %, which signifies a figure almost double as that of a single-jaw procedure ( Table 17 , Table 3 ). However , when these figures are entered into a statistical model , the % are not the aritmethic % ( 42 / 339 = 12,4 ) but estimated % based on the probitnormal model containing all groups (( 42 / 339 ; 20,6 %; ( 7.1 ; 43.2 ) 95 % CI )). Statistics were done in the SAS program and 95 % exact confidence intervals were calculated for the individual studies . In Table 18 the overall transfusion rates and corresponding 95 % confidence intervals were estimated using a probit-normal model . No significant difference between the predonation and the no-predonation policy could be shown ( p = 0.5047 ). The intra-study correlation was found to be significant . In the no-predonation policy the intrastudy correlation was 0.29 ( p = 0.0769 ). The intrastudy correlation in the predonation policy group was 0.26 ( p = 0.0960 ), ( Fig . 4 ). Four patients in the group with the predonation policy ( Table 18 ) received homologous blood : one in the series of Posnick et al . ( 2010 ) 56 who did not predonate , and three in the series of Moenning et al . ( 1995 ) 17 were patients that received both autologous and additional homologous blood . Total : 22 patients in the predonation policy group received a blood transfusion . Moenning ’ s patients who received both autologous and homologous blood were classified as having received autologous blood only . One would assume that the clinical message is clear . As long as bimaxillary surgery is straightforward , the need for blood transfusion remains well defined . Once additional procedures are executed , the risk for blood transfusion increases significantly . Table 19 summarizes the findings of the transfusion rates reported in the reviewed articles . In the predonation policy centers obviously the transfusion rate reflects a policy rather than a transfusion need . In the other centers without predonation policy the increasing complexity of the surgical orthognathic procedure goes along with an increased transfusion rate . The statistical model used to study bimaxillary surgery with a predonation policy yielded no statistically significant difference between simple and complex procedures ( p = 0.1257 ). The intrastudy correlation in the simple bimaxillary procedure group with predonation was 0.42 ( p = 0.0002 ). The intra-study correlation in the complex bimaxillary procedure group with predonation was 0.26 ( p = 0.1160 ). The statistical model used to study bimaxillary surgery with no-predonation policy yielded no statistically significant difference between simple and complex procedures ( p = 0.2571 ), in spite of the arithmetic
Table 14 . Transfusion policy according to author , in bimaxillary surgery without concomitant procedures .
Author |
Year |
Autologous transfusion policy Patients ( n ) with autologous transfusion |
% autologous transfusion |
Lassacher |
2008 |
1 |
2 % |
Moenning et al . |
1995 |
1 |
3 % |
Nkenke et al . |
2005 |
3 |
5 % |
Kessler et al . |
2006 |
6 |
9 % |
Felfernig-Boehm et al . |
2001 |
3 |
10 % |
Rohling et al . |
1999 |
21 |
17 % |
Gong et al . |
2002 |
16 |
19 % |
Rummasak et al . |
2011 |
58 |
28 % |
Hegtvedt et al . |
1987 |
33 |
34 % |
Guyuron et al . |
1996 |
12 |
60 % |
Böttger |
2007 |
64 |
78 % |
Puelacher et al . |
1998 |
37 |
82 % |
Lenzen et al . |
1999 |
69 |
100 % |
194
Stoma Edu J . 2017 ; 4 ( 3 ): 184-199 http :// www . stomaeduj . com
TRANSFUSION NEED IN ORTHOGNATHIC surgery - A REVIEW
(2009) 53 and Rummasak et al. (2011) 42 were not
retained because they did not give a transfusion
rate. The following papers were included in the
no-predonation policy: Ash and Mercuri, 1985 7 (8
patients); Choi et al., 2009 54 (61 patients); Kretschmer
et al., 2008 47 (36 patients); Landes et al., 2008 14 (13
patients); and Stewart et al., 2001 49 (2 patients).
Three papers with a predonation policy were retained
in this category: Blau et al., 1992 55 (30 patients);
Moenning et al., 1995 17 (155 patients); and Posnick
et al., 2010 56 (34 patients). Posnick et al. (2010) 56 did
not indicate a criterion of transfusion but believed
a level below 7 g/dL (Hc=21%) was a definite
indication for transfusion, with room for evaluation of
the clinical �����������Ʌ�͙�ͥ�������ɔ�ѡ�Ё��ٕ����)ɕ��������������ͅ�丁 ��ԁ�Ё��������Ȥ��ԁ�хѕ��ѡ��)ѡ�䁑�����Ё�͔�չ���ɴ��ɥѕɥ����ȁ���ѽ��Ʌѥٔ)�Ʌ�͙�ͥ��쁥�������������ѥ���́ɕ���ٕ�)�Ʌ�͙�ͥ������ѽ��Ʌѥٕ�䁉���ɔ����յ��хѥ��)���ѡ�����ѽ��Ʌѥٔ�������������������Ʌѥ���)A����������ѡ���ѡ�ȁ��ф�͡�ݕ������ɕ����Ѽ)��Յ��������ɥ�Ё�Ʌ�͙�ͥ����ɥѕɥ��ݡ������ͥ��ɥ��)��ѽ�����́�ȁ���������́�������Ʌ�͙�ͥ����Q��+�a�ɥѡ��ѥ��d��ٕɅ���ɕ�եɕ���Ё����������Ʌ�͙�ͥ��)�̀�ȸД��ݡ����ͥ������́������ɔ������Ё��Չ�����)ѡ�Ё�����ͥ�������܁�ɽ����ɔ��Q������ܰ�Q�����̤�)!�ݕٕȰ�ݡ���ѡ�͔�����ɕ́�ɔ���ѕɕ����Ѽ��)�хѥ�ѥ�����������ѡ�����ɔ���Ёѡ���ɥѵ�ѡ����(��ȼ�����ȰФ���Ё��ѥ��ѕ������͕�����ѡ���ɽ��д)��ɵ������������х�����������ɽ��̀���ȼ�������ؔ�(�ܸ���̸Ȥ�ԕ
$���)Mхѥ�ѥ�́ݕɔ���������ѡ��ML��ɽ�Ʌ�������Ԕ)�ᅍЁ�������������ѕ�م�́ݕɔ�����ձ�ѕ����ȁѡ�)����٥�Յ����Ց��̸�%��Q��������ѡ���ٕɅ����Ʌ�͙�ͥ��)Ʌѕ́�������ɕ����������Ԕ��������������ѕ�م��)ݕɔ���ѥ��ѕ���ͥ������ɽ��е��ɵ����������9�)ͥ��������Ё�����ɕ�������ݕ���ѡ���ɕ����ѥ��)����ѡ������ɕ����ѥ��������䁍�ձ�����͡�ݸ(��������ܤ��Q������Ʉ���Ց䁍��ɕ��ѥ���݅́��չ��Ѽ)���ͥ��������и�%��ѡ������ɕ����ѥ���������ѡ�����Ʉ�)��Ց䁍��ɕ��ѥ���݅̀���䀡�������䤸�Q������Ʉ�)��Ց䁍��ɕ��ѥ������ѡ���ɕ����ѥ��������䁝ɽ��)݅̀��������������������Ф�)��ȁ��ѥ���́���ѡ���ɽ���ݥѠ�ѡ���ɕ����ѥ��)�����䀡Q������ँɕ���ٕ�����������́�����聽��)���ѡ��͕ɥ�́���A������Ё������������ݡ���������)�ɕ����є������ѡɕ�����ѡ��͕ɥ�́���5���������Ё���(����Ԥ��܁ݕɔ���ѥ���́ѡ�Ёɕ���ٕ����Ѡ���ѽ������)��������ѥ��������������́�������Q�х���ȁ��ѥ����)���ѡ���ɕ����ѥ��������䁝ɽ���ɕ���ٕ���������)�Ʌ�͙�ͥ����5��������é��ѥ���́ݡ��ɕ���ٕ����Ѡ)��ѽ�����́�������������́������ݕɔ�����ͥ����)�́��٥���ɕ���ٕ����ѽ�����́����������)=���ݽձ�����յ��ѡ�Ёѡ��������������ͅ����́����ȸ)́������́����ᥱ������ɝ��䁥́��Ʌ���љ��݅ɐ��ѡ�)�������ȁ�������Ʌ�͙�ͥ���ɕ����́ݕ�����������)=��������ѥ������ɽ����ɕ́�ɔ��ᕍ�ѕ���ѡ��ɥͬ)��ȁ�������Ʌ�͙�ͥ������ɕ�͕́ͥ��������ѱ�)Q��������յ��ɥ�́ѡ���������́���ѡ���Ʌ�͙�ͥ��)Ʌѕ́ɕ���ѕ�����ѡ��ɕ٥�ݕ����ѥ���̸�%��ѡ�)�ɕ����ѥ��������䁍��ѕ�́��٥��ͱ�ѡ���Ʌ�͙�ͥ��)Ʌє�ɕ�����́��������Ʌѡ�ȁѡ������Ʌ�͙�ͥ��������)%��ѡ���ѡ�ȁ���ѕ�́ݥѡ��Ё�ɕ����ѥ���������ѡ�)���ɕ�ͥ�����������䁽��ѡ����ɝ�������ѡ����ѡ��)�ɽ����ɔ����́������ݥѠ�������ɕ�͕���Ʌ�͙�ͥ��)Ʌє�Q����хѥ�ѥ�����������͕��Ѽ���Ց䁉���ᥱ����)��ɝ���ݥѠ����ɕ����ѥ���������奕�������)�хѥ�ѥ�����ͥ��������Ё�����ɕ�������ݕ���ͥ����)�������������ɽ����ɕ̀��������ܤ��Q������Ʉ�)��Ց䁍��ɕ��ѥ������ѡ��ͥ���������ᥱ�����ɽ����ɔ)�ɽ���ݥѠ��ɕ����ѥ���݅̀���Ȁ��������Ȥ��Q��)���Ʉ���Ց䁍��ɕ��ѥ������ѡ��������������ᥱ����)�ɽ����ɔ��ɽ���ݥѠ��ɕ����ѥ���݅̀����(�����������)Q����хѥ�ѥ�����������͕��Ѽ���Ց䁉���ᥱ������ɝ���)ݥѠ�����ɕ����ѥ���������奕���������хѥ�ѥ�����)ͥ��������Ё�����ɕ�������ݕ���ͥ����������������)�ɽ����ɕ̀��������Ĥ��������є����ѡ���ɥѡ��ѥ�)Q������и�QɅ�͙�ͥ��������䁅���ɑ����Ѽ���ѡ�Ȱ��������ᥱ������ɝ���ݥѡ��Ё�������х�Ё�ɽ����ɕ̸)�ѽ�����́�Ʌ�͙�ͥ���������(���)�ѡ�ȁe��ȁ1��ͅ���Ȁ�����ĀȔ)5���������Ё�������ԀĀ̔)9�������Ё�������Ԁ̀Ԕ)-��ͱ�ȁ�Ё��������)����ɹ��� ������Ё�������Ā̀���)I��������Ё���������Ā�ܔ)�����Ё�������Ȁ���)Iյ��ͅ���Ё�������Ā������)!���ٕ�Ё�Ё�������܀�̀�Д)���ɽ���Ё��������Ȁ���)��ѝ�Ȁ���܀�Ѐ���)AՕ�����ȁ�Ё����������܀�Ȕ)1��镸��Ё��������������)A�ѥ���̀����ݥѠ���ѽ�����́�Ʌ�͙�ͥ�������ѽ�����́�Ʌ�͙�ͥ��)Mѽ����ԁ(�������Р̤���д���)����輽��ܹ�ѽ����ը����