Obiter Dicta Issue 3 - September 30, 2013 | Page 5

page 5 news Can we still trust the police? CITLALLY MACIEL News Editor happened. Each one has pointed fingers at the On Thursday, September 12, Constable Babak others. I have read the affidavits of some of Andalib-Goortani was found guilty of assault. the detainees. If I did not know better, I would The victim was Adam Nobody, a protester have thought that the events being described during the G20. When questioned about the there had occurred somewhere else, in a dicconviction, Toronto Police Chief Bill Blair tatorship perhaps. If what is being claimed by said that he is “always these detainees is true, the concerned when any way the police carried themincident might detract selves can be described as from the public’s perdeplorable. ception of their police service.” Chief Blair At the same time, there are also reminded us that a number of factors that there are many couramay have contributed to geous and dedicated this behaviour. Toronto was police off icers that chaos. There were thousands work hard to protect of people on the street that our city. There is no weekend. There were police doubt about it. Howcruisers set on fire, windows ever, that the frequency smashed, businesses burwith which we hear ADAM NOBODY SPEAKS TO PRESS glarized. The natural reacAFTER THE CONSTABLE THAT about police miscontion would have been fear. ASSAULTED HIM WAS FOUND duct is increasing has Fear tha H??????[??RSH??T L???XYHX[?H[?B??\?Z?HH?X?[Y[??[??]Y\?[??]\?^B??[??X\???Z?\??[?\?\??[??[?\?H?X?K??\??][?[??[???Z?H?\??\?\??X?[Y[??????\?Y ??\?\?X? H[???Y??X????H[Y?][????X?HZ\???X?\?[?H]?[?\????H?X?[X[??\???Y?[?\H??\?\?[?[?^?[?[?\?H?]XKH[???XY[[??H?\??]?H[?H]?\??[?]?[????HX\?[H??\\?Y??\???X\???????Z]H??HZ[?[H^\?Q]Z[?Y\??\?[?\??H?X?KHYYXKY[???H\??^\?[Y[???H??Y[??H??XX??H?[H\?HY??\?[??\??[???]??H????Y[?^\?Y[??B????[???X][???X?????[H????\?X????\??[?[]?[?Y[?? M? ? ? ???[]?????\??[????B??????^H??Y] ?Z]H ? ??^HY[ZYH?[??K?? ???????MR ? ???S?T?B??H?]\?X?BB??????[?[?\?H\?H?\?]?[??H]?[?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p?P?P??UB??????T?T????S??T?T???[? ? KH??\??H[?[[?X\??X?\?]?\??]\?[?[?\??X??X?????Z]\?B??X?]\?H?[Z[?[X?]?]HY?Y[???X?Y?[?H[?[]?[??Y?HY?]?\??Y[??\???[H[????Y??\??Y ?HY????X[[??[??\?[????\????]?B?\???\?H???H?Z[???Z^?Y ?\???[B?\?\\?[?HH[?H?\?[?\??H[?H??]??\?H?X?[Y[?]?H?Y[?X??\?Y???[???]?\??????YHZ[???Y??X??[?][?]??[[?XY??X?[Y[?????H?\?[?°????[?YY?Y?H M?[?^H H?\[X?\? ? H ? L??