Canadian Musician - January / February 2020 | Page 29
WOODWINDS
Andy Ballantyne is a noted Canadian saxophonist, composer, and educator. He is a member of the Juno
Award-winning Rex Hotel Orchestra and has also performed with jazz greats Rob McConnell, Don
Thompson, Maria Schneider, Carla Bley, and Bill Mays. Andy is on faculty at Humber College in Toronto.
His latest recording, Play on Words, is available on G-B Records. www.andyballantyne.com.
By Andy Ballantyne
Every Instrument
Is a Drum
M
Part 2
y column in the last issue dealt with the importance of
time feel for woodwind players and gave some general
approaches to metronome use in daily practice. In this
column, I will show some specific exercises I have been
using with my students and give some suggestions for
more advanced applications of this concept.
While the following exercises use material from the standard jazz rep-
ertoire, they could easily be adapted to almost any style of music. Playing
with a slow metronome providing only one click per bar would encourage
accurate subdivision in the allegro movements of a Baroque or Classical
sonata, for example.
It’s best to start this process with an eighth note-based melody in
4/4 time, so we’ll use the melody of “Ornithology” by Charlie Parker as
an initial exercise.
Set the metronome to 40 bpm. That click represents a whole note (so
you will actually be playing the song at 160 bpm), but the click is not beat
one; it is the “and” of beat four.
Getting your head around this may take some time, and I strongly
recommend singing the melody first before attempting to play it. You
may also find tapping your foot on beats one and three while you sing
(and play) helpful. Ex. 1 is the first few bars of “Ornithology” (transposed
for alto sax) with arrows showing the notes that should line up with the
metronome click:
Ex. 1
The goal is to play the entire tune with the metronome on the “and” of
beat four. Go ahead and play with a swing feel if that feels natural to you.
Remember that the metronome is only there to confirm that you are playing
in time. Don’t just guess where the click is going to land; feel the subdivision
internally and play with confidence. If it doesn’t line up, notice if you are
ahead or behind, make an adjustment, and then try again.
There are a few different ways to play the last four bars of “Ornithology.”
I recommend Ex. 2:
Ex. 2
This is actually the most difficult part of the exercise for most people be-
cause the emphasis is on the strong downbeats of one and three instead
of the “and” of four. I often “loop” these four bars and do them over and
over again with my students until it feels solid.
Simpler tunes are actually more challenging because you have to feel
the subdivision internally during sustained notes or rests. For the second
tune, we will work with “Blue Bossa” by Kenny Dorham. The metronome
is the same: 40 bpm representing the “and” of beat four. Keep the eighth
notes perfectly straight (not swung) to match the Latin feel of the song.
Ex. 3
Ex. 3 is the first few bars with arrows showing the click. Just getting started
with this one is a challenge because you have to play the pickup on beat four
and then land on beat one of the next bar with a click exactly in between
those two notes. It’s easy to get thrown off.
There is a deceptively tricky bit near the end of “Blue Bossa.” Notice
what happens in bars 13 and 14 of the melody (Ex. 4):
Ex. 4
For some reason, most people find it difficult to play this rhythm accu-
rately; it tends to get behind in the second bar. You may think you are
playing it accurately (l know I did before I worked on this exercise), but
the metronome never lies!
This leads back to another point I mentioned in part one: even if you
aren’t completely successful, you are still improving your rhythmic feel
just by attempting these exercises. Try to embrace the challenge and
don’t get discouraged. And if you are worried that this will make your
playing sound too rigid or mechanical, rest assured that woodwind play-
ers generally sound all too “human” when it comes to time feel. This won’t
turn you into a robot.
Of course, the “and” of four is just one option for this approach. As you
get comfortable with the concept, you can (and should) shift the click
around to any eighth note in the bar. Then you can devise other ways of
subdividing the bar and explore different time signatures. As a somewhat
extreme example, I’ve been working on a study in 5/16 from Guy Lacour’s
28 Etudes pour Saxophone with the metronome on the fourth sixteenth
note of every bar. And yes, it’s hard!
Follow me @andyballantynemusic on Facebook or Instagram and
I will post some videos over the next few weeks demonstrating
these concepts.
CANADIAN MUSICIAN 29