Research from ASH ’ s online peer-reviewed journal , Blood Advances in a Different Vein
CLINICAL NEWS
Carfilzomib Benefits Outweigh Potential for Cardiac Toxicity in Relapsed / Refractory Myeloma
While clinical trials of the proteasome inhibitor carfilzomib for the treatment of multiple myeloma ( MM ) showed varying incidence rates of cardiovascular adverse events ( AEs ), a review of data from the phase I , II , and III trials leading to its approval suggest that the improvements in patient survival are worth the relatively low risk of cardiac failure or hypertension .
“ Carfilzomib-based regimens have produced clinically meaningful responses and [ have ] shown significant improvement in the depth and duration of responses in [ this setting ] … including a nearly eight-month increase in overall survival ,” lead author Ajai Chari , MD , of the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai in New York , told ASH Clinical News . “ While optimization of cardiovascular health is important for all patients , the findings of this study demonstrate the risk of cardiovascular events is far outweighed by the benefit of carfilzomib treatment – as evidenced by improvements in overall survival ,” he said .
The pooled analysis , which was published in Blood Advances , included data from 11 clinical trials evaluating carfilzomib in patients with relapsed / refractory MM that reported incidence of cardiovascular-related AEs , comprising a total of 2,044 patients who received at least one dose of carfilzomib .
The researchers analyzed studies for all grade and grade ≥3 cardiovascularrelated AEs of interest , including cardiac failure , dyspnea , hypertension , and ischemic heart disease . For the purposes
“ This study highlights the difficulties in studying toxicities observed in single-arm studies in a disease like [ multiple myeloma ].”
– AJAI CHARI , MD
TABLE . Treatment-Emergent Cardiovascular Adverse Events
Carfilzomib ( KRd ) ( n = 392 )
ASPIRE ENDEAVOR FOCUS
Control ( Rd ) ( n = 389 )
Carfilzomib ( Kd ) ( n = 463 )
Control ( Vd ) ( n = 456 )
Carfilzomib ( carfilzomib ) ( n = 157 ) of the study , treatment-emergent AEs were defined as events that began on or following the first day of therapy or AEs that presented at baseline and worsened in severity following treatment .
Three trials ( ASPIRE , ENDEAVOR , and FOCUS ) also included analyses of the cardiac safety profile in 1,012 carfilzomib-treated patients compared with 998 patients in control arms who were treated with either lenalidomide plus dexamethasone , bortezomib plus dexamethasone , or best supportive care , respectively .
In the pooled analysis of all 11 trials , the most frequently reported cardiovascular-related AEs included anygrade incidences of :
• cardiac failure ( 6.7 %)
• hypertension ( 18.5 %)
• dyspnea ( 31.9 %)
Grade ≥3 incidences of cardiac failure , hypertension , and dyspnea were reported in 4.4 percent , 5.9 percent , and 4.5 percent of patients , respectively .
Across the three phase III trials , the incidence of cardiac AEs was numerically higher in carfilzomib than control groups , but , after adjustment for duration of
Control ( BSC ) ( n = 153 )
Treatment-emergent cardiac AEs of interest , any-grade |
Cardiac failure |
25 ( 6.4 ) |
16 ( 4.1 ) |
38 ( 8.2 ) |
13 ( 2.9 ) |
12 ( 7.6 ) |
7 ( 4.6 ) |
Hypertension |
62 ( 15.8 ) |
32 ( 8.2 ) |
120 ( 25.9 ) |
44 ( 9.6 ) |
25 ( 15.9 ) |
9 ( 5.9 ) |
Dyspnea |
89 ( 22.7 ) |
70 ( 18.0 ) |
143 ( 30.9 ) |
78 ( 17.1 ) |
25 ( 15.9 ) |
19 ( 12.4 ) |
Ischemic heart disease |
23 ( 5.9 ) |
18 ( 4.6 ) |
13 ( 2.8 ) |
9 ( 2.0 ) |
3 ( 1.9 ) |
0 |
Treatment-emergent cardiac AEs of interest , grade ≥3 |
Cardiac failure |
15 ( 3.8 ) |
7 ( 1.8 ) |
22 ( 4.8 ) |
8 ( 1.8 ) |
9 ( 5.7 ) |
5 ( 3.3 ) |
Hypertension |
22 ( 5.6 ) |
8 ( 2.1 ) |
44 ( 9.5 ) |
12 ( 2.6 ) |
6 ( 3.8 ) |
0 |
Dyspnea |
12 ( 3.1 ) |
8 ( 2.1 ) |
26 ( 5.6 ) |
10 ( 2.2 ) |
3 ( 1.9 ) |
0 |
Ischemic heart disease |
13 ( 3.3 ) |
8 ( 2.1 ) |
8 ( 1.7 ) |
7 ( 1.5 ) |
1 ( 0.6 ) |
0 |
Cause of death Cardiac failure |
3 ( 0.8 ) |
4 ( 1.0 ) |
2 ( 0.4 ) |
2 ( 0.4 ) |
2 ( 1.3 ) |
2 ( 1.3 ) |
Hypertension |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
Dyspnea |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
Ischemic heart disease |
3 ( 0.8 ) |
2 ( 0.5 ) |
0 |
3 ( 0.7 ) |
0 |
0 |
AE = adverse event ; K = carfilzomib ; Rd = lenalidomide , dexamethasone ; Kd = carfilzomib , dexamethasone ; Vd = bortezomib , dexamethasone ; |
BSC = best supportive care |
Cardiac failure and hypertension events are listed as standardized MedDRA query , narrow scope , and ischemic heart disease is listed as standardized MedDRA query , broad scope . All data are n (%), unless indicated otherwise . treatment exposure and follow-up , the incidences were similar between the treatment groups ( TABLE ).
Small proportions of patients in each of the phase III trials experienced cardiac failure events that led to missed doses of carfilzomib ( 2.6 %, 3.5 %, and 3.2 % in ASPIRE , ENDEAV- OR , and FOCUS , respectively ). Most of these patients also were able to restart carfilzomib ( 70 %, 75 %, and 80 %, respectively ). Mortality related to cardiac failure was low across studies , the authors reported , ranging from 0.4 to 1.3 percent . “ Treatment with carfilzomib in more than 1,000 patients in phase III studies was associated with low rates of cardiac events ; however , the rates of treatment reduction and / or discontinuation and deaths due to cardiac events were very low and comparable in both arms ,” Dr . Chari added .
In a substudy of 159 cardiopulmonaryevaluable patients enrolled in the phase III ENDEAVOR trial ( 80 who received carfilzomib plus dexamethasone and 79 who received bortezomib plus dexamethasone ), the incidence of left ventricular ejection fraction ( LVEF ) reduction also was low : One patient in the bortezomib group experienced a > 10 percent reduction in LVEF at 24 weeks , and three patients in each arm experienced a significant LVEF reduction at any time during the study period .
“ As hematologist-oncologists , we are tasked with optimizing the risk-benefit profile of treatments for our patients ,” Dr . Chari remarked . “ This study highlights the difficulties in studying toxicities observed in single-arm studies in a disease like MM , where patients have comorbidities due to aging and myeloma itself .”
Limitations of the analysis included the lack of double-blind studies available for assessment and the lack of cardiologybased AE reports in each study analyzed . While the randomized design of the phase III trials worked to address confounding variables , Dr . Chari noted , the lack of blinding ; coding of nonhematologic toxicities by hematology / oncology staff ; and longer therapy times in the experimental arm relative to the control arm presented additional challenges in assessing attributable risk .
The researchers added that “ careful monitoring and management of cardiovascular risk factors , including blood pressure and volume status , are recommended for all myeloma patients as good clinical practice .” ●
The authors reported a financial relationship with Onyx Pharmaceuticals , which funded the study .
REFERENCE
Chari A , Stewart AK , Russell SD , et al . Analysis of carfilzomib cardiovascular safety profile across relapsed and / or refractory multiple myeloma clinical trials . Blood Advances . 2018 ; 2:1633-44 .
26 ASH Clinical News October 2018