Africa Water, Sanitation & Hygiene Africa Water & Sanitation & Hygiene Nov-Dec 2017 | Page 13
Water Supply
•
you happen to be an intersexed child, born with
ambiguous genitals and/or reproductive organs,
whose parents have decided (despite social pressure
and pressure from the medical community) not to
subject their child to surgery until the child can
participate in that decision.”
Restricted access to toilets for some aside, they are also
spaces that can keep historically excluded groups “in their
place”, often rationalized by elaborate notions of purity
and pollution. These notions are best known in South Asia,
but are widely prevalent in many other parts of the world as
well. For instance, J.J. Lawrence and colleagues document
the taboo against using same toilets as in-laws, members
of the opposite sex, or different generations within a
family in some Zambian communities. Indeed, one of the
most egregious ways in which toilets are used to assert an
oppressive status quo is when only certain Dalit castes are
assigned the task of cleaning them, thereby rendering both
the cleaners and the toilets “impure”.
With the growing power of the erstwhile subaltern peoples,
toilets are emerging as arenas for political assertion. Take
the case of the United States, where the movement against
segregated toilets is symbolic of the assertion of sexual
minorities. This assertion is premised upon the fact that
gender identity, not sex at birth, should determine individual
choice. The backlash is equally vehement and has played
out in the legal and social realms, with laws passed for and
against segregated toilets. A more muted movement for
the rights of domestic workers in many parts of the world
advocates for their right to use toilets within the homes
where they work – something that has historically been
anathema. Take also the Dalit assertion in India that has
rallied against the gruesome practice of manual scavenging,
leading to its ultimate ban.
In sum, toilets are undoubtedly good for sanitation, health
and women’s empowerment, but they can also be potent
instruments for equality and inclusion. This can happen
when policy is sensitive to the role of toilets as contested
spaces and responds to the clamor of historically excluded
groups against their potential tyranny.
About the Author
Maitreyi Bordia Das is the World Bank’s
Global Lead for Social Inclusion. Based
in Washington DC, she works on issues
of inequality and exclusion and on the
design and implementation of social policy
and programs. Among other publications,
Maitreyi is also the lead author of the 2013 report, “Inclusion
Matters: The Foundation for Shared Prosperity” and most
recently of “Scaling the Heights: Social Inclusion and
Sustainable Development in Himachal Pradesh”. She started
her career as a lecturer in St Stephen’s College, University of
Delhi, has been a MacArthur Fellow at the Harvard Center of
Population and Development Studies and worked as advisor
to the United Nations Development Program. She has a PhD
in Sociology (Demography) from the University of Maryland.
Before joining the World Bank, Maitreyi was in the Indian
Administrative Service (IAS)
About IFC About WSP
IFC, a member of the World Bank Group, is the largest
global development institution focused exclusively on
the private sector. We help developing countries achieve
sustainable growth by financing investment, mobilizing
capital in international financial markets, and providing
advisory services to businesses and governments. For more
information, visit: www.ifc.org and www.ifc.org/ssawa. The Water and Sanitation Program (WSP) is a multi-donor
partnership administered by the World Bank to support
poor people in obtaining affordable, safe, and sustainable
access to water and sanitation services. WSP provides
technical assistance, facilitates knowledge exchange, and
promotes evi dence-based advancements in sector dialogue.
For more information, visit: www.wsp.org.
IFC - CBA Building, 4th Floor | Upper Hill, Mara/Ragati Road
Nairobi, Kenya, P.O. Box 30577-00100
Contact: Will Davies | [email protected] | +254 (0) 717 133 177
World Bank - Water and Sanitation Program | Hill Park Towers, Upper Hill Road
Nairobi, Kenya, P.O Box 30577
Contact: Yolande Coombes | [email protected] | +254 20 322 6309
Africa Water, Sanitation & Hygiene • November - December 2017
13